CALL NOW TO SPEAK TO AN ATTORNEY 1-844-HAFFNER
213-514-5681

Experienced. Aggressive. Reliable. We Fight for You.

  • No Hidden Fees Involved
  • No Obligation to Continue Beyond the Case Review
  • Get All Your Legal Questions Answered
click here for a free consultation

Notable Case Results

  • $ 7,500,000

    Brain Injury
    Settlement
  • $ 1,480,000

    Truck Driver
    Wage Class Action
  • $ 1,000,000

    Fraud/Breach of
    Contract

Associations

Recent Results

$ 7,500,000

Brain Injury Settlement

$ 1,480,000

Truck Driver Wage Class Action

$ 1,000,000

Fraud/Breach of Contract

Touch below for a free injury consultation.

click here for a

free consultation

no fees until you get paid

What If PG&E Is Responsible For The Butte Fire — Insurance Claims And Third Party Liability Under California Law

Click below to share this article:

Hblogpowerline3_202

The Butte fire has destroyed more than 500 homes in Calaveras and Amador counties. According to a recent lawsuit, the fire may have been started by a Pacific Gas & Electric Co. power line coming into contact with a tree. This gives rise to the prospect that PG&E could haveliability for damages caused by the Butte fire. However, the fire damages are also likely covered, at least in part, under homeowners’ insurance policies. When a wildfire like the Butte fire, or any event that causes loss, occurs because of the fault of a third party, and the loss is also covered by insurance, questions often arise regarding the interplay between obtaining policy benefits from your insurer, and damages from the responsible third party.

It is entirely proper to present an insurance claim for damages from the Butte fire, obtain available insurance policy benefits, and also sue the responsible third-party, which in this case may be PG&E. There are many items of damage people can suffer from a wildfire that are not covered by insurance. For instance, shrubs, trees, and vegetation are often subject to a low sub-limit in insurance policies. However, under California law, a third-party tortfeasor who injures someone’s “timber, trees, or underwood” is responsible for three times the full value of the trees and vegetation. (California Civil Code §3346.) In addition, many homes are often underinsured, and a homeowner cannot collect beyond the limits of the insurance policy. However, there is no limit on the liability of a third-party like PG&E for the damages its conduct causes. Further, people can recover for emotional distress against a responsible third-party, but do not get policy benefits for emotional distress. In addition, PG&E, because it operates a utility line, may be liable for inverse condemnation, which provides for attorney’s fees that would not be available an insurance policy.

A third-party like PG&E is not entitled to deduct the amount you were paid by your insurance company from its liability for the damages they caused. This is known as the collateral source rule, and provides that where a person who suffers a loss receives “some compensation for his injuries from a source wholly independent of the tortfeasor” then the amount received is “not be deducted from the damages” the third-party wrongdoer owes. (Hrnjak v. Graymar, Inc. (1971) 4 Cal.3d 725, 729.) However, practically speaking, your insurance company has a right of “subrogation” for the amount they paid for the loss against the culpable third-party, which in this case allegedly is PG&E. (21st Century Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (2009) 47 Cal.4th 511, 518.) Thus, in all likelihood, an insured can only obtain from the responsible third-party damages above and beyond what the person received from their insurance company.

In a wildfire, homeowners often suffer significant losses which are often not fully recoverable under insurance, but are obtainable in a suit against the entity responsible for causing the fire. Persons who have suffered damage as a result of the Butte fire have every right to make an insurance claim, and seek recovery from any culpable third parties responsible for starting the fire.

RESULTS

$15,000,000

PROPERTY DAMAGE / BAD FAITH

$10,000,000

Bad Faith

$7,500,000

Medical Malpractice

$750,000

Bad Faith / Disability

$815,000

Wrongful Death

$1,000,000

Construction Defect
view all

INJURED ? CALL 213-514-5681

or

FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW FOR AFREE CASE REVIEW

  • NO PRESSURE
  • SPEAK WITH AN ATTORNEY
  • NO HIDDEN FEES
[]
1 Step 1
Type your name here & click nextyour full name
Phoneyour full name
Commentsmore details
0 /
Previous
Next
powered by FormCraft
All Fields Required